Monday, March 12, 2012

Writing while marginalized - Pt. 1

I have always recoiled from the idea that certain conversations by marginalized people can only be held behind closed doors (The old "Don't air our dirty laundry" thing.). But now I'm wondering if some things simply cannot be discussed effectively within a mainstream context without “othering” the group in question.

It was the latest article in The Washington Post’s series on black women that got me thinking. Lonnae O’Neal Parker is a good writer. Her effort was measured and thoughtful. She is a black female writer in a space where the voices of black women are not the majority. The Washington Post has accompanied its coverage with online discussions and the actual voices of black women--something that doesn't often happen. Now, I complain all the time about the absence of black women in mainstream media. I hate that they so often ignore us. But here The Washington Post is paying attention to black women and I find I'd rather they didn't. Because despite all the panels and surveys and a black woman writer and the presence of black female voices, it still reads as exotification and demonization because of the context and because of who is observing the conversation.

I recall feeling the same way last year, when I took part in a CNN online article about the phenomenon of black women with natural hair enduring unwanted touching. Several black women honestly shared our lived experiences with a black writer, who had navigated similar waters. But a brief web article cannot hold the nuance and history related to African American hair and beauty standards and power dynamics. And, based on the nasty attacks several of us endured as a result of the article, in the end, it served more to inflame than educate. (More here.)

Last week I found myself working on an article about an element of black culture for a mainstream feminist publication. My criticism of the Post series and the aftermath of the CNN article began haunting me. Because here I was explaining a black issue for consumption by a mostly non-black audience and perhaps opening the door to the same “othering” that I hate.

So, I wondered: How do other folks who are members of historically marginalized groups, and who write about race and gender and sexuality, wrestle with this? Do they? Should we? Are there topics writers will not or should not discuss outside of a "safe space"? Are there story ideas writers reserve for "of color" or GLBT spaces?

I asked some smart, writerly, social justice-minded folks to weigh in. And I'll be sharing their thinking all this week. First up, Latoya Peterson of Racialicious.


Study seeks to identify black views of marriage

Dr. Ebony Utley is conducting a survey and needs African American respondents. Please read her note below and consider participating.
If you are at least 18 years old and self-identify as Black or African American, you are invited to participate in a study about marriage. This study is important because it gives African Americans an opportunity to speak about marriage for themselves instead of having mediated representations speak for them. The online survey takes approximately 15 minutes. All participants are invited to enter a raffle to win a $50 gift card. Please share this survey with any and everyone that you know. I am part of a research team trying to recruit 1,000 respondents. You can access the survey at bit.ly/blkmarriage. Email questions to ebony.utley@csulb.edu. Sincerely, Dr. Ebony Utley www.theutleyexperience.com

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...